phpc.social is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
A server for PHP programmers & friends. Join us for discussions on the PHP programming language, frameworks, packages, tools, open source, tech, life, and more.

Administered by:

Server stats:

798
active users

Re: recent boost

They say even a stopped clock is right twice a day, but I think it's the wrong frame to look at it.

Can a stopped clock tell you the time? Can you know when a stopped clock is right, without the use of another clock? Can it give you information about the current time?

LLMs are the same way, they are also right sometimes. Can you tell when? Without consulting another more reliable source of information?

hachyderm.io/@thomasfuchs/1127

Hachyderm.ioThomas 🔭✨ (@thomasfuchs@hachyderm.io)Every time I post about LLMs being useless (because they can't think) people reply with "but it works for me". No, it doesn't work for you. That's the point. You can't know when it's lying or being subtly wrong, unless you do the work yourself to research if what it's saying is actually correct. If you say "I always check" why use the LLM in the first place? Now it's double the work. (Of course no one actually does the checking, they only say they do.)

@quirk @thomasfuchs even a working clock is only an approximation of reality

And as we understand it right now, that's still highly relativistic

what even is reality?

This isn't an argument in favour of LLMs or the use of the term "AI" to give anyone the remote impression of intelligence

It's rather a commentary on how deeply ingrained the marketing speak has been, for many many centuries, that we think of objects that do one thing as though they can do another

Simon :laravel:

@quirk @thomasfuchs We are victims of our own over-simplifications (and highly susceptible to those who have something to sell)

In fact, I have a remedy for that! Just take this snake oil twice a day