Follow

Has anybody done any sort of comment system that embeds and/or links Mastodon/Fediverse posts that reference a page? It seems like it would be an interesting way to provide comments and expose those comments to readers...

/cc @feditips

@mwop @feditips I’m not sure if Mastodon implements it, but other ActivityPub instances might implement Webmentions. @Gargron

@mwop @feditips @Gargron In fact, I’m very interested in this, since I want to implement Webmention support in the next iteration of my blog.

@ramsey That's exactly what I'm hoping to do with mine as well. Going to see if the AcivityPub plugin for WP gives me any ideas. @feditips @Gargron

@mwop

This may not be exactly what you're after, but you can link WordPress blogs to the Fediverse using the ActivityPub plugin:

mstdn.social/@feditips/1076388

@feditips @mwop I happened across this the other day. It’s on my to-do list to try but it might give you some ideas?

twit.social/@leo/1077581231316

@mwop @feditips
It seems to me that -- if such a thing is possible -- a consolidated Federated identity might serve as the basis of, e.g. my Mastodon posts serving as the basis of, say, a Lemmy thread.
CAVEAT: I am insufficiently technical to actually know what I'm talking about...

@feditips @mwop not the same thing, but related: fed.brid.gy/
And Brid.gy itself picks up Twitter comments and web mentions, so it looks like that area and the people doing it might be fruitful places to look

@mwop @feditips afaik it won't work in a fully generic way (... kinda like hashtags don't; there is no one central entity that looks at all links submitted & sends out updates); agreeing with @ramsey though that it might be a thing that some instances do implement!

@ssafar The point of the ActivityPub and Webmention specs is that it shouldn’t rely on a central entity. 😉 @mwop @feditips

@ramsey @mwop @feditips well yes :) but then if someone on ActivityPub instance X posts a link to blog A but X doesn't support Webmentions, you can't do anything on the "A" side to fix this

(... maybe if every instance Y that X federates with would look at links & send out slightly redundant webmentions... e.g. if Pleroma decided to do this, but Mastodon not, it might work. Having looked at my nginx logs: currently, no one is doing it.)

@feditips @mwop @ssafar That would probably start using a lot of resources. If an instance doesn’t implement it, there’s not a lot you can (or should) do to fix it.

@ramsey @feditips @mwop ... actually, thinking about it...

... would it even use extra resources?

if you post a link to fedi, your server will already get a wave of http get's with all the instances with people who follow you, to fetch e.g. a page title to embed

hitting you with yet another wave if you support webmentions (... which they can tell based on the page they just fetched) wouldn't be even that bad :)

@ramsey @feditips @mwop (okay that's obviously extra resources, but... only if you specify that you want webmentions)

@feditips @ssafar @mwop I think the spec also prevents other actors from saying some other domain mentioned your page. I could see that being misused, if there wasn’t some form of verification.

@mwop @feditips Don't know if it's of interest, but I ran across this article on using Mastodon for comments: leo.fm/2022/02/comments/

@mwop @feditips I know some people are using Fedi as a comment tool.
Don't remember all of them but one example is this post [1] from @robertwgehl.

[1]: scholar.social/@robertwgehl/10

@tfardet Oh, that's interesting - for each blog post, he then creates a Mastodon post linking to it; the "load comments" button on the blog post goes and grabs any replies to the Mastodon post.

That could be interesting... /cc @ramsey

@mwop @feditips I may be using Lemmy in a similar way to what you're thinking about. Https://read.widerweb.org/ is where I've started collecting links for the Transmutable News Weekly. It doesn't really meld with Mastodon AFAIK, though.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
PHP Community on Mastodon

Open source. Open community. We are dedicated to building and enriching the PHP community.